The Pros and Cons of Selling Art on Online Marketplaces

In recent years, the art world has undergone a significant transformation with the rise of online marketplaces. These digital platforms have revolutionized the way artists showcase and sell their work, offering unprecedented opportunities and challenges.

This article explores the advantages and disadvantages of selling art on online marketplaces, providing valuable insights for artists considering this avenue for their creative endeavors.

The Evolution of Art Sales in the Digital Age

Traditionally, artists relied on galleries, art fairs, and personal networks to sell their work. However, the advent of the internet and e-commerce has opened up new possibilities for artists to reach a global audience.

Online marketplaces such as Etsy, Saatchi Art, and Artfinder have emerged as popular platforms for artists to showcase and sell their creations directly to buyers worldwide.

According to a report by Hiscox, the online art market reached $4.82 billion in 2019, representing a 4% year-on-year increase. This growth trend highlights the increasing acceptance and popularity of purchasing art through digital channels.

Pros of Selling Art on Online Marketplaces

1. Global Reach and Exposure

One of the most significant advantages of online marketplaces is the ability to reach a vast, global audience.

Artists are no longer limited by geographical constraints and can showcase their work to potential buyers from around the world.

  • Increased visibility for emerging artists
  • Access to international markets
  • Opportunity to build a diverse collector base

2. Lower Barriers to Entry

Online marketplaces have significantly reduced the barriers to entry for artists looking to sell their work.

Unlike traditional galleries, which often have stringent selection processes, many online platforms allow artists to create accounts and start selling with minimal requirements.

  • Reduced overhead costs compared to physical galleries
  • No need for expensive exhibition spaces
  • Flexibility to manage sales independently

3. 24/7 Availability

Online marketplaces operate round the clock, allowing potential buyers to browse and purchase art at any time.

This constant availability can lead to increased sales opportunities and convenience for both artists and collectors.

4. Data-Driven Insights

Many online platforms provide artists with valuable analytics and insights about their audience, sales performance, and market trends.

This data can help artists make informed decisions about pricing, marketing strategies, and creative direction.

5. Diverse Revenue Streams

Online marketplaces often offer various ways for artists to monetize their work beyond traditional sales.

These may include print-on-demand services, licensing opportunities, and commission-based projects.

Cons of Selling Art on Online Marketplaces

1. Intense Competition

While online marketplaces offer increased exposure, they also come with heightened competition. With millions of artists vying for attention, it can be challenging to stand out and attract buyers.

  • Oversaturation of certain art styles or genres
  • Difficulty in establishing a unique brand identity
  • Pressure to constantly produce new work to remain visible

2. Commission Fees and Pricing Pressure

Many online marketplaces charge commission fees on sales, which can significantly impact an artist’s profit margins. Additionally, the abundance of options available to buyers can lead to pricing pressure and the expectation of lower prices.

For example, Etsy charges a 5% transaction fee plus a 3% + $0.25 payment processing fee, while Saatchi Art takes a 35% commission on original artworks.

3. Limited Personal Connection

Selling art online can lack the personal touch and emotional connection that comes with in-person interactions. Artists may find it challenging to convey the story and inspiration behind their work through digital means alone.

4. Potential for Intellectual Property Issues

The digital nature of online marketplaces can make it easier for unscrupulous individuals to copy or reproduce artworks without permission.

Artists must be vigilant in protecting their intellectual property and may need to invest time and resources in addressing infringement issues.

5. Dependence on Platform Algorithms

Many online marketplaces use algorithms to determine which artworks are shown to potential buyers.

These algorithms can be opaque and subject to change, potentially affecting an artist’s visibility and sales performance without warning.

Case Studies: Success Stories and Cautionary Tales

Success Story: Ashley Longshore

Ashley Longshore, an American pop artist, has successfully leveraged online platforms to build a thriving art business.

By utilizing Instagram and her own e-commerce website, Longshore has attracted a large following and sold millions of dollars worth of art directly to collectors.

Cautionary Tale: The Challenges of Mass-Produced Art

Some artists have faced criticism for selling mass-produced prints or reproductions on online marketplaces, potentially diluting the value of their original works.

This highlights the importance of carefully considering how to balance accessibility with exclusivity in the online art market.

Strategies for Success on Online Art Marketplaces

To maximize the benefits and mitigate the challenges of selling art online, artists can consider the following strategies:

  • Develop a strong personal brand and unique artistic style
  • Invest in high-quality product photography and descriptions
  • Engage with potential buyers through social media and email marketing
  • Diversify across multiple platforms to reduce dependence on a single marketplace
  • Offer a mix of original works and more accessible prints or reproductions
  • Stay informed about platform policies and algorithm changes
  • Continuously analyze sales data and adjust strategies accordingly

The Future of Online Art Sales

As technology continues to evolve, the online art market is likely to see further innovations. Virtual and augmented reality experiences, blockchain-based provenance tracking, and AI-powered curation are just a few of the developments that may shape the future of online art sales.

According to the Art Basel and UBS Global Art Market Report 2020, online sales accounted for 9% of the total global art market value in 2019, with projections indicating continued growth in this sector.

Conclusion

Selling art on online marketplaces offers both exciting opportunities and significant challenges for artists.

The global reach, lower barriers to entry, and potential for diverse revenue streams make these platforms an attractive option for many creators. However, intense competition, commission fees, and the potential for intellectual property issues are important considerations to keep in mind.

Ultimately, success in the online art market requires a strategic approach that balances the benefits of digital platforms with the unique value of an artist’s work.

By carefully weighing the pros and cons and implementing effective strategies, artists can leverage online marketplaces to build successful and sustainable careers in the ever-evolving art world.

About the Author

Picture of Alex Gray

Alex Gray

Hi 👋 I'm Alex. I am a self described creative entrepreneur (and also a fine artist). You could say I'm an abstract painter by day and a tech nerd by night. I've been building digital assets since 2008 and now I create software companies and teach courses on Udemy.
🎨

Start with the Art World 101 free course to learn exactly what you need to start getting opportunities to sell and show your art ↓

Subscription Form